http://comics.ign.com/articles/662/662147p1.html
Scott Pilgrim 1 and 2 Review
Hilary Goldstein
IGN.com

"What I assumed would be a trite, goofy and overdone manga-ripoff is instead one of the coolest books of 2005. And it takes place in Canada of all places. I love Scott Pilgrim."

"O'Malley manages to keep the emotional core grounded, even in such extreme situations such as when a public library is turned into a lost scene from Kill Bill."

I'm college trained for this sort of thing.

I'm afraid I only check your site for my Scott Pilgrim updates.

On another note. I love "Australia" very much. I just got that album a couple weeks ago.

I started with the "Lola" album and that's what got me hooked on the Kinks. I also got Muswell Hillbillies which is--as you said, awesome in a different way. I highly recommend getting it and giving it some time. It's a little more challenging because it's primarily "Americana" music which might be right up your alley actually.

The four albums we've mentioned is what I call (so far) the "4 Essential Kinks Albums". According to critics the earlier stuff is too "British Invasion" and the later is too "Rock Opera".

I'll figure it out eventually.

http://www.popmatters.com/pm/comics/reviews/scott-pilgrim-vols-1-3
Scott Pilgrim, Vols. 1-3
Greg Oleksiuk
PopMatters
"Scott Pilgrim conveys an atmosphere that irresistibly draws the reader in. Perhaps it is the universal tale of falling in love and having to struggle to keep it; perhaps it is the numerous references to video games, comic books, and other geeky pleasures; or perhaps it is just because all of these factors meld together so well, that rather than being cheesy or silly, this comic comes across as genuine, entertaining and enthralling."

NOW WHERE IS MY PRIZE?

http://www.popcultureshock.com/brendan-laura-adans-picks-scans-september-6-2007/42574/
Brendan, Laura & Adan’s Picks & Scans - September 6, 2007
Brendan McGuirk, Laura Hudson, and Adan Jimenez (but mostly McGuirk)
PopCultureShock
"A perfect potion of equal parts ensemble romantic melodrama, coming of age (a little too late), ADD level kineticism, video-game culture and the subsequent effect on youth definitions of progress, and general awesimeotivity, Scott is the best friend comics ever made. "

http://www.penny-arcade.com/2006/04/03
Lanternalia
Jerry Holkins/Tycho
Penny Arcade

"these books are pure sugar whose appeal is very nearly beyond mortal tastings."

Thats it, but maybe a good quote?

And on that note

http://www.pvponline.com/newspro/archives/arc1-2006.html
Scott Kurtz
Pvp
"They're fun, silly and bad-ass all rolled into a little pocket-manga sized book."

http://www.sequentialtart.com/reports.php?ID=4128&issue=2005-10-01
Lee Atchison
SequentialTart.com
"Scott Pilgrim is a great comic, and you should go read it now."

http://www.paneltopanel.net/article/view/14066/1/1431/
James Kochalka
Panel To Panel .NET
"Some things about it are so good it hurts."
"...it's SUPER Canadian."

www.ravemagazine.com.au
Scott Pilgrim Vs The World (Vol 2)
Chris Harms
Rave magazine #705
"The appeal of O'Malley's book is in its innate sense of absurd fun, combining elements of alt-comic romance with Canadian indie rock and manga-inspired super-power duels."
"The mix of hyper-real mysticism and day-in-the-life rock & roll antics might be a stretch for some, but if you can get in tune with Scott Pilgrim's world, the rewards are endless."
****1/2

http://www.aintitcool.com/node/23210#9
Free Scott Pilgrim review/Scott Pilgrim 1 & 3 review
Vroom Socko/Humphry Lee
Ain't It Cool News

"Take a look at the nutrition labels on the soda Scott is buying[...] without having a chuckle, I dare you."
Vroom Socko

"[W]henever you think you've got it figured out, it comes at you again in a way you didn't expect." Humphry Lee


There's more that I and others wrote, but AICN's archives are acting all wonky right now, so I can't find the proper links. Happens every time they update their server...

http://www.discorder.ca/oldsite/regulars/05septtextually.html

Andy Hudson
Discorder Magazine
Textually Active, Sept 2005

"The whole effect, whether you’re in Toronto, Vancouver, or anywhere and crushing to Plumtree, makes you feel very familiar in Scott Pilgrim’s “precious little life”."

http://hobotaku.blogspot.com/2007/10/scott-pilgrim-volumes-1-3.html
Scott Pilgrim Volumes 1-3
Nick Popio
http://hobotaku.blogspot.com/
"I can't remember when I first heard about Scott Pilgrim or why I ended up picking up the first volume, but I wish I could travel back in time and high-five whomever or whatever caused me to do so."

In an effort of full disclosure, I'm the one who wrote the review.

http://www.popmatters.com/pm/comics/reviews/scott-pilgrim-vols-1-3
Greg Oleksiuk
Popmatters.com
"It shows what comics are capable of, and that fun comics do not have to lack intelligence and complexity."

http://comicsworthreading.com/2006/06/26/scott-pilgrim-the-infinite-sadness-2/
Scott Pilgrim & the Infinite Sadness — Recommended
Johanna Draper Carlson
Comic Worth Reading
"The book’s deeper than it appears at a quick glance. At first, the reader may only notice the video-game-style slugfests, but the cast and their relationships are becoming ever more complicated, with development revealed both through flashbacks and the characters’ growing historical awareness as they come to terms with their pasts."

http://www.readaboutcomics.com/2004/08/09/scott-pilgrim-vol-1-scott-pilgrims-precious-little-life/
Scott Pilgrim Vol. 1: Scott Pilgrim’s Precious Little Life
Greg McElhatton
Read About Comics
" Scott Pilgrim’s Precious Little Life truly is a synthesis of English-language and Japanese comics. Using the best of both worlds, in many ways this is a real sort of “crossover” comic..."
"...I think people who have found their sensibilities catered to by either school of comic creating will find a lot to love in Scott Pilgrim."

http://www.amazon.com/Scott-Pilgrim-Vol-Infinite-Sadness/dp/193266422X
Publishers Weekly (via Amazon.com)
"The weirdest, funniest and coolest Western variation on the manga aesthetic to date, and the third volume is even more hilarious than the first two."

http://comics.ign.com/articles/710/710766p1.html
Scott Pilgrim & the Infinite Sadness Review
Hillary Goldstein
IGN.com
"O'Malley managed to get tangled in his own web of wackiness, delivering a decent, but far less exceptional addition to the series."

http://www.silverbulletcomicbooks.com/reviews/115758287189494.htm
Scott Pilgrim & the Infinite Sadness Review
Stephen L. Holland
Silver Bullet Comic Books
"For those of you who have been in suspended animation for the last two years, this is the best comic going right now!"

http://fossen.blogspot.com/2006/05/scott-pilgrim-infinite-sadness.html
Scott Pilgrim & the Infinite Sadness
Mark Fossen
Focused Totality (blog)
"For all the changes, though, this is still Scott Pilgrim: charming, funny, smart, and one of the best things happening in comics today."

http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,1204690,00.html
Book Review: Scott Pilgrim & the Infinite Sadness
Tom Russo
Entertainment Weekly
"Does It Deliver? Does a vegan diet give you the power to tear a hole in the moon? In Pilgrim's random universe, that's a big yeah, dude."

Offtopic,but some kid did a Scott Pilgrim spoof/rip off Live Action movie trailer and uploaded it to YT. It's "cute" and pretty funny. Here's the link:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Ctl055Sz5A

URL
"Let's Start With Launchpad McQuack"
Dawn Davis
www.thebookblog.ca
"This comic is made for all of us who grew up in the nineties. Don’t suffer any longer without exeperiencing the awesome that is Scott."

I made this!